Jay on Journals

Some thoughts on keeping a notebook from Jay Montville:

on one for the blogs I read recently, the author (who shall remain nameless not because I’m trying to protect her, but because I can’t find the link, so I don’t actually remember her name) said that journalling is not writing.

*gasp*!

I know! Because most writing advice websites and books and instructors strongly advocate journals. “Carry a notebook at all times!” they say. “Jot down things!” “Do this writing exercise!”

But the blogger I read before said all this is crap (not her words). “Writers WRITE”, was the basic tenor of her advice. “They don’t fool around with ‘jotting.'”

And I have to say, I agree with her. And I keep a journal.

But those two things are very different–I keep a journal because I like it.

Notebooks Help Iranian Children Cope With Not Liking School

Here’s a quote from an article in the Tehran Times:

What to do if you don’t like school

Another good idea is to write down your feelings about school in a journal. You can use a journal or diary or just write in an ordinary notebook. It’s a great way to let out emotions that may be stuck inside you. And you don’t have to share what you’ve written with others.

But if you’re a kid who’s the outcast at school, be careful what you do with that notebook! You don’t want to end up like Harriet the Spy, with everyone reading what you’ve written about them! I remember being completely distressed as a 7th grader when I lost a wonderful notebook. I hadn’t written anything nasty about my classmates, but I was just dying thinking someone might reveal embarrassing things I’d written about myself!

Notebooks, journals, sketchbooks, diaries: in search of the perfect page…